To understand the significance of the sweeping military purges in China and how Beijing is reacting to America’s war with Iran, Jan is sitting down with eminent China scholar Robert Suettinger, a former CIA and State Department intelligence analyst, a senior advisor at The Stimson Center, and author of “The Conscience of the Party: Hu Yaobang, China’s Communist Reformer.”
“There's no question of the fact that Xi Jinping is now less of a dominant leader than he was six or eight months ago,” Suettinger says.
Earlier this year, Xi purged two top generals from the CCP’s military brass, on the heels of earlier purges last year.
Now, only two of the originally seven members of the Central Military Commission remain.
One of them is Xi himself; the other, General Zhang Shengmin, is a political commander and, like Xi, has no combat experience.
After the January purges, Xi issued an order to the military demanding that everyone acknowledge him as the head of the military commission.
“The silence from all those military commands has been deafening and has been noticed by everybody,” Suettinger says.
In the Chinese Communist Party itself, Xi is also facing trouble.
The CCP is not a monolithic party, he told me, but a complex entity with many competing factions:
“There's a Shanghai group, there's a Shandong group, there's a Shaanxi group, and they all don't like each other,” Suettinger says.
Suettinger believes that Xi’s many purges have unified opposition against him not only in the military but also within the Communist Party.
“Xi is hated by almost everybody in China,” he said.
Another reason the cracks in the system, as he put it, are beginning to be more evident is that the Chinese economy hasn’t been doing well in many years:
“The Chinese people are very unhappy that their wealth opportunities are disappearing.
“Graduates coming out of colleges are not able to find good jobs.
“People who have good jobs are losing them.
“People who are operating in the gig economy are losing their jobs.
“The farmers don't have anything to do when they go back home.”
People outside of China don’t usually know how poor vast numbers of Chinese citizens still are, Suettinger told me.
China’s Premier Li Keqiang himself stated in May 2020 during a press conference that 600 million people live below the poverty line and don’t even earn enough to rent a room in mid-sized Chinese cities.
Where is China’s totalitarian system headed?
The system, Suettinger argued, is way more fragile than it looks.
“It is brittle, and when it breaks, it tends to break hard, and it tends to melt in ways that are not predictable,” he said.
Notably,
The CCP has not come out to meaningfully support its longtime ally,
Iran.
The CCP has long utilized Iran to distract America and keep its focus on the Middle East, Suettinger says, but now, to Beijing’s chagrin, America is effectively neutralizing this longtime CCP proxy.
